
The last time there was a game comparable to this was on November 18, 2006 when #1 Ohio State played arch-rival #2 Michigan in Columbus to end the regular season for both teams. The game turned out to be all that it was hyped up to be, with the final score being 42-39 in favor of the Buckeyes. Unfortunately, the weeks after caused the game to lose quite a bit of its luster. Immediately following the game, the hot topic was whether or not the game should be replayed for the National Championship, as there were no remaining undefeated teams to challenge the Buckeyes. When USC was upset by UCLA the final week to lose their second game of the season, the cries for a rematch between the Wolverines and Buckeyes grew louder.
When the final BCS standings were released, the one-loss SEC Champion Florida Gators edged out Michigan for the #2 spot. Many people disagreed with the decision, believing that voters pushed a better and more deserving Michigan team out of the game, only to avoid a rematch. The opening line for the game was Ohio St. -8 (they were favored to win by 8 points, for those not up with the sports lingo), a huge spread for a National Championship game. Florida ended up exposing the Troy Smith led Buckeyes, 41-14. The college football world was stunned. After the bowl games, it looked like people should have been arguing for Florida to play LSU in the National Championship game, as LSU obliterated Notre Dame in the Sugar Bowl by an identical score of 41-14, and Michigan lost to USC 32-18. The Big 10 teams, referred to by many as the two best teams in the country, had flopped in the BCS, and it now appeared that the regular season matchup between the rivals was not worth the hype.
What would be worth the hype was the Southeastern Conference's dominance in college football. With the beatdown of the Buckeyes, Florida kicked off what would be FIVE straight National Championships for the SEC. Today, the SEC has proven itself to be THE elite conference in college football.
Since the Bowl Championship Series (BCS) began in 1998, the SEC is 7-0 in national championship games. No other conference has a winning record. Only the Big 12 can match the SEC in national championship appearances. But the conference has only two crystal footballs to show for those seven appearances (Oklahoma in 2000 and Texas in 2005). No argument can be made against the recent dominance of the Southeastern Conference - and this is why SEC teams are often heard chanting "S-E-C" at the end of big wins against non-conference opponents.
Through 9 weeks of college football, LSU and Alabama hold the Top 2 spots in the BCS rankings by a sizeable margin. One of these juggernaut teams has to lose this weekend, and if history has taught us anything, the team that makes it through this cage match will be holding the crystal football on January 9, 2012.
I think this is LSU's best team in recent years. That's a bold claim considering the Tigers recent success - two national championships since 2003 from what I believe are the second and third best teams in that time period (I've got a soft spot for the 2006 team). LSU has been tested far more than Alabama. LSU's strength of schedule is #13 in the country - a strength of schedule that is hurt by playing Northwestern St., which should not take away from the big wins the team has. LSU embarrassed an Oregon team (#5 total offense) who has not been challenged since. The Tigers also stomped on current 24th-ranked West Virginia, who boasts the nation's #13 total offense. The best offense that Alabama has played is that of #7 Arkansas, who has the #25 offense in the country. Alabama also has only the #39 SOS in the country (compared with LSU at #13).
LSU's most unbelievable feat is being ranked at the very top of the three major human polls right now. They started the season ranked two spots behind Alabama (#2) at #4. It is rare for a team with the prestige of Alabama to drop in the polls without losing. Alabama started the season with 30 total first place votes between the AP and USA Today polls (the Harris Poll does not come out until Week 7 in an attempt to let teams' résumés, rather than preseason hype, determine the rankings). This week, Alabama remains at the #2 spot, but they only have 28 first place votes between the two polls. LSU began the year ranked #4 in the country with only 3 total first place votes. They can now boast 88 of the 117 first place votes between the two polls.
I have had the fortune to attend two LSU games this year (Oregon and Auburn), and this football team has passed the "eye test." They just "look good." The confidence that LSU plays with is remarkable. Against Auburn, every time LSU scored (which happened a lot in the 45-10 blowout), you could see the kickoff team (full of big name players) start to excitedly get together on the sideline for what is usually thought of as a routine special teams play. They were eagerly waiting to light the return man up. It was almost like it was a contest on who could lay a bigger hit. Every kickoff ended with a bang and the crowd yelling, "OOOOHHHH!" You couldn't help but think that the Auburn return men were terrified to take the field at some point. Here is one of the big plays from LSU freshman WR Jarvis Landry. Out of high school, he was ranked the #4 WR in the country by Rivals.com, but on a deep LSU team, he finds the field as a big-hitting special teams player... at least for now.
The week LSU played Auburn, arguably LSU's two best players were suspended for violation of team rules (reportedly failed drug tests). Running back Spencer Ware was leading (and still does lead) the run-heavy team in rushing yards, and cornerback Tyrann Mathieu had been receiving Heisman hype, as a DEFENSIVE player! Before the suspensions were announced, LSU was favored by an unbelievable 24 points against the #19 team in the country. After the announcement, the line quickly dropped to -20. LSU easily covered, winning by 35 points! This is the same team who became an underdog against #2 Oregon after losing their starting QB Jordan Jefferson to a suspension. Back-up QB Jarrett Lee was able to step in and lead LSU to a huge win, 40-27. Suspensions cannot hurt a team that has this much talent.
Alabama and LSU are two VERY similar teams. Both teams boast big-time defenses with great running games. Alabama RB Trent Richardson is currently one of the favorites to win the Heisman Trophy; his running mate Eddie Lacy is also a terror for opposing defenses. And the LSU backfield tandem of Spencer Ware and Michael Ford (among others) is no easy task to defend either. Alabama might have the big name, but I don't give them a big advantage if any in the running game.
I will dismiss the homefield advantage for Alabama, simply because home field has not played much of a role in the recent games between the two teams. The home team is 3-3 in the last 6 years.
Let's take a look at the quarterbacks, as I am sure that both defenses are going to plan to force the quarterbacks to win the ball game. This is an easy choice for me. I'm trusting 2 senior QBs for LSU over an unproven first-year starter for Alabama. LSU's Jarrett Lee has thrown for 13 TDs against just one interception this season, while Jordan Jefferson (former starter who still sees meaningful playing time) has thrown 2 TDs without an interception. A.J. McCarron has thrown for 10 TDs and 3 interceptions, having a nice year for Alabama. But he has not faced any defense close to what LSU defensive coordinator John Chavis will throw at him this weekend.
I think that LSU has the biggest playmaker on the field, and he doesn't even play on the offensive side of the ball. Look for LSU CB Tyrann Matheiu to come up with a big forced fumble, interception, or even punt return (just about the only play he has yet to make this year). Those big plays are what gave him the Heisman talk along with the nickname "Honey Badger." Tyrann "Honey Badger" Mathieu takes what he wants, and this week, he wants to take away Alabama's title hopes.
This game is splitting hairs, honestly. Both of these teams could crush any other team in the country. It is unfortunate that these two have to play before that actual national championship. That's the cost of playing in the SEC. If you aren't convinced that LSU will win this game, I don't blame you. Alabama is a great team. But I myself will be surprised to see the Tigers lose this Saturday, and I expect them to win by at least two scores.
My final insight into why I think LSU will win is a simple pattern. LSU won the National Championship in 2003 in the New Orleans Super Dome. Four years later, in 2007, they won it again... in the New Orleans Super Dome (as it rotates every four years). Well, here we are again... 4 years later... and the game is once again being played in the New Orleans Super Dome. LSU fans often like to say, "The Dome is Home," and I'm going to agree. I picked the Tigers to win it all in the preseason, I'm picking them to win this weekend, and I'm picking them to win it all this season (sorta rhymed, huh?).
When the final BCS standings were released, the one-loss SEC Champion Florida Gators edged out Michigan for the #2 spot. Many people disagreed with the decision, believing that voters pushed a better and more deserving Michigan team out of the game, only to avoid a rematch. The opening line for the game was Ohio St. -8 (they were favored to win by 8 points, for those not up with the sports lingo), a huge spread for a National Championship game. Florida ended up exposing the Troy Smith led Buckeyes, 41-14. The college football world was stunned. After the bowl games, it looked like people should have been arguing for Florida to play LSU in the National Championship game, as LSU obliterated Notre Dame in the Sugar Bowl by an identical score of 41-14, and Michigan lost to USC 32-18. The Big 10 teams, referred to by many as the two best teams in the country, had flopped in the BCS, and it now appeared that the regular season matchup between the rivals was not worth the hype.
What would be worth the hype was the Southeastern Conference's dominance in college football. With the beatdown of the Buckeyes, Florida kicked off what would be FIVE straight National Championships for the SEC. Today, the SEC has proven itself to be THE elite conference in college football.
Since the Bowl Championship Series (BCS) began in 1998, the SEC is 7-0 in national championship games. No other conference has a winning record. Only the Big 12 can match the SEC in national championship appearances. But the conference has only two crystal footballs to show for those seven appearances (Oklahoma in 2000 and Texas in 2005). No argument can be made against the recent dominance of the Southeastern Conference - and this is why SEC teams are often heard chanting "S-E-C" at the end of big wins against non-conference opponents.
Through 9 weeks of college football, LSU and Alabama hold the Top 2 spots in the BCS rankings by a sizeable margin. One of these juggernaut teams has to lose this weekend, and if history has taught us anything, the team that makes it through this cage match will be holding the crystal football on January 9, 2012.
![]() |
Both coaches have championships with their current teams |
So now it is time to try to predict which team will come out on top this weekend. I'm going with LSU. And I expect them to win by at least 10 points.
I think this is LSU's best team in recent years. That's a bold claim considering the Tigers recent success - two national championships since 2003 from what I believe are the second and third best teams in that time period (I've got a soft spot for the 2006 team). LSU has been tested far more than Alabama. LSU's strength of schedule is #13 in the country - a strength of schedule that is hurt by playing Northwestern St., which should not take away from the big wins the team has. LSU embarrassed an Oregon team (#5 total offense) who has not been challenged since. The Tigers also stomped on current 24th-ranked West Virginia, who boasts the nation's #13 total offense. The best offense that Alabama has played is that of #7 Arkansas, who has the #25 offense in the country. Alabama also has only the #39 SOS in the country (compared with LSU at #13).
LSU's most unbelievable feat is being ranked at the very top of the three major human polls right now. They started the season ranked two spots behind Alabama (#2) at #4. It is rare for a team with the prestige of Alabama to drop in the polls without losing. Alabama started the season with 30 total first place votes between the AP and USA Today polls (the Harris Poll does not come out until Week 7 in an attempt to let teams' résumés, rather than preseason hype, determine the rankings). This week, Alabama remains at the #2 spot, but they only have 28 first place votes between the two polls. LSU began the year ranked #4 in the country with only 3 total first place votes. They can now boast 88 of the 117 first place votes between the two polls.
I have had the fortune to attend two LSU games this year (Oregon and Auburn), and this football team has passed the "eye test." They just "look good." The confidence that LSU plays with is remarkable. Against Auburn, every time LSU scored (which happened a lot in the 45-10 blowout), you could see the kickoff team (full of big name players) start to excitedly get together on the sideline for what is usually thought of as a routine special teams play. They were eagerly waiting to light the return man up. It was almost like it was a contest on who could lay a bigger hit. Every kickoff ended with a bang and the crowd yelling, "OOOOHHHH!" You couldn't help but think that the Auburn return men were terrified to take the field at some point. Here is one of the big plays from LSU freshman WR Jarvis Landry. Out of high school, he was ranked the #4 WR in the country by Rivals.com, but on a deep LSU team, he finds the field as a big-hitting special teams player... at least for now.
The week LSU played Auburn, arguably LSU's two best players were suspended for violation of team rules (reportedly failed drug tests). Running back Spencer Ware was leading (and still does lead) the run-heavy team in rushing yards, and cornerback Tyrann Mathieu had been receiving Heisman hype, as a DEFENSIVE player! Before the suspensions were announced, LSU was favored by an unbelievable 24 points against the #19 team in the country. After the announcement, the line quickly dropped to -20. LSU easily covered, winning by 35 points! This is the same team who became an underdog against #2 Oregon after losing their starting QB Jordan Jefferson to a suspension. Back-up QB Jarrett Lee was able to step in and lead LSU to a huge win, 40-27. Suspensions cannot hurt a team that has this much talent.
Alabama and LSU are two VERY similar teams. Both teams boast big-time defenses with great running games. Alabama RB Trent Richardson is currently one of the favorites to win the Heisman Trophy; his running mate Eddie Lacy is also a terror for opposing defenses. And the LSU backfield tandem of Spencer Ware and Michael Ford (among others) is no easy task to defend either. Alabama might have the big name, but I don't give them a big advantage if any in the running game.
I will dismiss the homefield advantage for Alabama, simply because home field has not played much of a role in the recent games between the two teams. The home team is 3-3 in the last 6 years.
Let's take a look at the quarterbacks, as I am sure that both defenses are going to plan to force the quarterbacks to win the ball game. This is an easy choice for me. I'm trusting 2 senior QBs for LSU over an unproven first-year starter for Alabama. LSU's Jarrett Lee has thrown for 13 TDs against just one interception this season, while Jordan Jefferson (former starter who still sees meaningful playing time) has thrown 2 TDs without an interception. A.J. McCarron has thrown for 10 TDs and 3 interceptions, having a nice year for Alabama. But he has not faced any defense close to what LSU defensive coordinator John Chavis will throw at him this weekend.
I think that LSU has the biggest playmaker on the field, and he doesn't even play on the offensive side of the ball. Look for LSU CB Tyrann Matheiu to come up with a big forced fumble, interception, or even punt return (just about the only play he has yet to make this year). Those big plays are what gave him the Heisman talk along with the nickname "Honey Badger." Tyrann "Honey Badger" Mathieu takes what he wants, and this week, he wants to take away Alabama's title hopes.
This game is splitting hairs, honestly. Both of these teams could crush any other team in the country. It is unfortunate that these two have to play before that actual national championship. That's the cost of playing in the SEC. If you aren't convinced that LSU will win this game, I don't blame you. Alabama is a great team. But I myself will be surprised to see the Tigers lose this Saturday, and I expect them to win by at least two scores.
My final insight into why I think LSU will win is a simple pattern. LSU won the National Championship in 2003 in the New Orleans Super Dome. Four years later, in 2007, they won it again... in the New Orleans Super Dome (as it rotates every four years). Well, here we are again... 4 years later... and the game is once again being played in the New Orleans Super Dome. LSU fans often like to say, "The Dome is Home," and I'm going to agree. I picked the Tigers to win it all in the preseason, I'm picking them to win this weekend, and I'm picking them to win it all this season (sorta rhymed, huh?).